This is the third time I’ve made a little butter. It is sinfully easy to do, it’s just not as economical as buying butter. We have access to raw milk from Spring Bank Farm in Brush Valley, where they do not poison their cows, and therefore anyone who consumes the milk. The only drawback with soaring gas prices is that it is a 28 mile round trip, so we don’t indulge that often. The milk sells for circa $6.50 a gallon, and has a good pint or so of cream on top. (I’ll get a picture of that next time…) We buy the milk when the opportunity presents itself.
First step is to pour off the cream. I pour until it looks like I have most of the cream – a little milk getting in with the cream doesn’t seem to effect the process (unless that is the reason I must beat it so long?)

Cream in the mixing bowl. There is over two cups in the KitchenAid Professional 6 quart bowl,
but the room is needed as it splatters mightily when whipped.
It is also nice that the Professional has a plastic cover to help control the mess.
Second step: Turn the mixer to a high speed. Beat/whip until butter separates from the whey. The cream goes through soft peak, to hard peak. Then after what seems a long time, the whey will separate from the butter. I must confess on this batch that I missed seeing the soft and hard peak, and I finally stopped the mixer to see why it wasn’t separating – and it had already separated. OOps…

This is the end result when whipping.
Note the splatter on the bowl – better than painting the kitchen with it.
Third step: Line a colander with cheese cloth and place over a bowl. Pour the whey/butter into the colander to separate the two. Save the whey/buttermilk(?) for use in baking. (Actually it tastes just like milk.)

Draining the whey from the butter.
Be sure to save the by product for some delicious baking.
Fourth step: Use the cheese cloth to gently squeeze whey from the butter. The butter will be very soft (especially on a warm day), which means don’t squeeze too hard or it will be imbedded in the cheesecloth.

The drained butter is ready to squeeze to remove excess whey.
Fifth (and final) Step: Rinsing the butter. It is important to remove the buttermilk to keep the butter from going rancid. Rinse with cold water until the water runs clear. You can then shape your butter into blocks, sticks or whatever shape you want. I just wrap it waxpaper or saranwrap and gently shape into a block or stick. If there is more than one stick, I will freeze one (in case I was not careful enough to remove all the buttermilk).


The two products of buttermaking: a bit of butter and some buttermilk.